top of page

Nintendo’s Mario Magic - Something My PS5 and Xbox Can’t Replace

  • Writer: NathanielCrossdale
    NathanielCrossdale
  • Dec 11, 2025
  • 3 min read


Super Mario Bros.





Intro

I’ll never forget the first day I got my hands on a PlayStation 2 for my 6th birthday. Playing Ratchet and Clank on the beautiful, revolutionary machine is one of my core gaming memories. Of course, gamers know that in the following seventh generation of consoles, the Xbox 360 became the must-have machine of the moment, and so further memories were added to the gaming story when I was slicing Locust in Gears of War and traversing the Halo rings as Master Chief. 


PlayStation vs Xbox

PlayStation has built its reputation on delivering cinematic, emotionally rich, and mechanically polished action-adventure experiences. From the PS2 era onward, Sony invested heavily in first-party studios that prioritised narrative depth and immersive worlds. This tradition flourished on the PS3 and PS4 with standout titles like Uncharted, God of War, and The Last of Us. These games emphasised exploration, puzzle-solving, and character development, offering players a more reflective and story-driven experience compared to the twitch reflex demands of competitive shooters.


While PlayStation leaned into storytelling, Xbox carved out its identity as the shooter capital of gaming—especially during the Xbox 360 era. Microsoft’s robust online infrastructure via Xbox Live revolutionised multiplayer gaming, making it the go-to platform for competitive shooters. Franchises like Halo and Gears of War defined the console’s DNA, offering fast-paced, skill-driven gameplay with rich multiplayer modes and gritty aesthetics. The Xbox 360 also became the preferred platform for Call of Duty players, thanks to timed DLC releases and smoother online performance. It was the console that made fragging friends after school a cultural ritual, with party systems and matchmaking that set the standard for online play. For gamers who thrived on adrenaline, precision, and squad-based tactics, Xbox was the undisputed champion.


Both Sony and Microsoft have started iconic gaming franchises that are near and dear to my heart, and some I hope will continue (Sony, give us another Uncharted!). However, there is one franchise from the other iconic gaming company, Nintendo, which I have not been able to let go of, no matter how extensive my gaming history with Xbox and PlayStation has become. That is the Mario franchise. This beloved franchise is the primary reason why I pick up a Nintendo console each generation and has provided me with some of my most special memories as a gamer. Mario is one of the rare gaming franchises that can resonate on an emotional and technical level. 

Xbox vs PlayStation 5

Nintendo x Mario

Nintendo’s Mario franchise is not just a cornerstone of gaming history—it’s a masterclass in game design that has captivated players for over four decades. From his humble beginnings as “Jumpman” in Donkey Kong (1981) to his breakout role in Super Mario Bros. (1985), Mario helped revive the video game industry and set the gold standard for platformers. What makes the series exceptional is its consistently tight, responsive controls, intuitive level design, and endlessly creative mechanics that teach players through play rather than instruction. Each instalment—from the revolutionary Super Mario 64 to the gravity-bending Galaxy games and the inventive Odyssey—introduces fresh ideas while retaining the joyful essence of Mario’s world.


The franchise’s success lies in its universal appeal, genre versatility, and polished presentation, making it accessible to newcomers and rewarding for veterans. With over 800 million games sold and a cultural footprint that spans theme parks, merchandise, and movies, Mario isn’t just a game character—he’s a global icon of fun, imagination, and timeless design. It’s because of Mario’s endless endurance as a staple in my gaming life that I will eventually pick up the Nintendo Switch 2, despite most Nintendo franchises not being something that I play regularly.


If you’re into Super Mario Odyssey like I am, then the new Donkey Kong Bananza is definitely something to check out. It’s made by the same team, and you can really feel that Odyssey-style creativity in how the game plays. The worlds are big and open, full of secrets and challenges, and Donkey Kong’s moves are surprisingly smooth—lots of swinging, bouncing, and smashing through stuff. It’s got that same sense of freedom and exploration, but with a bit more chaos and muscle. Honestly, it feels like the next step in 3D platforming, and if you loved hunting down Power Moons, you’re going to have a blast chasing Golden Bananas.


Super Mario Bros. Wonder

Wrap-Up

In the end, while PlayStation and Xbox have given me unforgettable moments through cinematic storytelling and competitive thrills, nothing quite matches the timeless joy of Mario. Nintendo’s magic lies in its ability to create games that are endlessly inventive, emotionally resonant, and universally fun—reminding me why I fell in love with gaming in the first place. No matter how powerful the hardware or how expansive the worlds on other consoles become, I’ll always find myself coming back to Mario, where imagination, charm, and pure gameplay brilliance never go out of style.


Comments


bottom of page